Hello everybody, as promised I am back with a special treat today. I finally had the time to go and spend some time in a store (in the last few weeks I have been so busy that I only went in for quick returns/purchases) and got to try on (almost) the whole holiday collection. It was nice to see all the new stuff and I had a lot of fun, even if ended up not buying enything besides two items that were on sale. I hope that you will have some fun as well.
Today I am going to post the pics of the regular stuff while later tonight or tomorrow it's going to be party time!
Let's start with the Heart me sweater that many loved in the last rollout but received some bad reviews on the JCA. I understand why: the fabric is really sub-pair for JCrew, it is a thin blend of wool, nylon and cashmere and I bet that the cashmere content is 5%. Anyway, I kind of liked it (you will see it a lot in these pics because it is one of the only tops that I grabbed, and the neutral colors made it a good match for many bottoms) but I bet that this will go on sale before Valentine's Day (I feel that the only occasion to show up with a big heart on my chest is a kids Valentine's party). I am trying a XS in the acorn/black colorway, it fits TTS:
Another top I was curious about is the Wynter sweater in sequin stripe. Initially I wanted to try the black/ivory colorway but the clay blue was more special (although more difficult to wear, because it isn't really an evening sweater in these colors and sequins in daylight are soooooo 2010). This one runs SMALL. I am trying the S here and it just fit:
A top that I admired in the catalog is the Cashmere fair isle sweater I loved, loved, loved this sweater in the catalog and website pics and also when I saw it in store. The cashmere feels very plus and the colors are great. However, this is the most strangely-fitting sweater ever, in that the sleeves seams are very low, like a dolman-sleeve but not . It has to do with the intarsia patterns that runs across the chest and through the sleeves. This is the XS:
Last sweater, a in-store only offering (I think). Sort of a mix between a sweatshirt and a sweater, in a "nordic" pattern. I thought that some of you would find this kind of cute but I forgot to look at the tag yesterday and when I saw it today again at the Collection store I was shocked to find out that it retails for $148 and (wait) has a 84% acrylic content (12% wool and 4% nylon or vicevera). Really? Anyway, this is the XS:
Let me say just a word on the striped leggings that I am wearing with the sweater: AWESOME. These are on sale and I have always been strangely attracted to them but I thought I would never dare. They are superslimming (I know I am fairly small but I don't always look good on leggings)> This is the XXS and they are perfect on me because there isn't any extra fabric, which is always a issue with leggins for us petites. The fabric is 30% wool and 70% rayon and I really recommend to give them a try if you can get them with the 30% off. Now I have only to find something that covers my butt to wear them out:
Let's continue with the new arrivals. I hadn't taken the Cafe capri in wool plaid in the fitting room because I wasn't interested but a lady in another fitting room had just tried them and they were my size so I gave them a try while I was at it. LOVE! They were unusually flattering and fun. However I know I wouldn't reach them very often because they are very loud so I didn't buy them. They seem to run big. This is the 00 and I am usually a 0 in pants with very few exceptions:
On the other hand the much talked about Cafe capri in leopard jaquard were a disaster. Too high-waisted, baggy and plain unflattering (size down for sure). This is a 0:
Speaking of leopard, I saw the Leopard sweater-dress at the Collection store today and tried it on. This is very itchy (it's mohair), sheer and borderline hooker (and all this for $225!) What were they thinking? The fit is good though, this is the XS:
I also couldn't resist trying the No.2 Pencil skirt in harvest tweed when I saw it. It was thinner in texture than I expected (which is good for the fit IMO), even if I had tried on the pants in the other colorway. This is a 0, it fits like a dream. I don't reach my pencil skirts that often so I am not going to buy it FP but I will try to catch it on a good sale. I tried it with my sweater untucked and tucked:
There are a few golden metallic threads in the tweed that I hadn't noticed at first (I tried to take a pic but they don't show):
They also had the tweed pencil skirt with the bow that was mentionned on the JCA recently. I didn't like this one as much (the colors are a little bit drab) and it didn't fit me as well for unknown reasons ;-). This is a 0 as well (the bow looks a little bit sad but maybe it was this one in particular):
This is retail-only for the time being and the price is $148. Someone on the JCA mentionned that it's called No. 2 Pencil Skirt in Glen Plaid (Item #55689).
Last, many JCA were curious about the Fair Isle merino leggins. I have to say that they looked much better than expected (wool leggings is generally the type of leggings that add weight and shorten my figure) and they weren't itchy (at least not while I was trying them on. I think they are something like $95% merino and 5% spandex). What I didn't particularly liked is the camel hem that gives the illusion of something cropped (it looks like a piece of leg). This is the XS (there was a little bit of extra fabric but not that much):
Personally, I wouldn't spend that much in a pair of leggings but if you are a fan of the fair isle pattern and are in Canada or NY, Joe Fresh has a much cheaper alternative (albait a black and white) for $29:
Congratulations, you made it to the end of this post! If you have any questions let me know and stay tuned for the party items!
What's your favorite item from the holiday collection? Which of the items that I showed in this post did you like most?




















Hi Ema! Thanks for posting all the pictures and your comments for these new arrivals.
ReplyDeleteWhew, where to begin. That was a fun post. :) The first tweed pencil skirt looked great on you, also the plaid pants, and I do still like the heart sweater although I'll probably return mine when it arrives. A couple of the leggings were interesting, also liked the fair isle sweater on you. The leopard pants are disappointing. I loved those when I first saw them styled for fall but couldn't believe they are poly for the price!
Thanks again for the great reviews.
How much were the striped leggings on sale for in store? Thanks!
ReplyDeleteoh I'm crushed ... didn't realize daytime sequins were passe ;) And you've confirmed what I've heard about the "perfect" Valentine's Day outfit: the heart me sweater and leopard jacquard capri are not so good. Save me some money on the leopard sweater dress. But I'll continue to wear sequins daytime because I can't help being a magpie!
ReplyDeleteI have the heart me sweater & don't see what the issue is with it. I like it quite a bit. I was expecting a thin sweater, so maybe that's why I'm not disappointed. The dream fabric is more disappointing than the heart me. I think it's the same content in both. I'm hoping it's not because that means pilling. Anyway, with 25% off, I'm happy. Thanks for all the great pics!! I'm now curious to see the Wynter in person.
ReplyDeleteThanks for all the great pics and reviews! Those plaid capris are adorable on you and actually so is the Heart sweater. The Harvest tweed skirt is cute on you as well. (Really now, what isn't?!) I love that bow on the tweed skirt! I so wish it came in a more exciting colorway though, boo. Maybe at sale time.
ReplyDeleteEma - I feel vindicated if a wee thing like you looks wretched in those leopard jacquards, imagine how I looked in the size 6. They were disaster personalified!
ReplyDeleteI had originally ordered the fair isle leggings and then changed my mind when I saw the camel binding as well. I will definitely go check on the Joe Fresh version!
My personal favourite on you was the tweed skirt and plaid pants!
thanks for the reviews.
ReplyDeletei like the plaid pants on you and the skirt with the bow.
have you tried the vintage thermal sweatshirt? thoughts?
TIA
A bigger closet, thanks and glad that you liked the post! Yes, I couldn't believe either that those pants are poly. On the positive side at least it is a real jaquard, not a print like the other jewel ones. Let us know what you think of the heart me sweater.
ReplyDeleteSummerilla, they were still $54.99 in store (like the last time that I saw them online). HTH!
tiffany rose, I think the heart me sweater is cute (not $88 cute, but cute) but it is one of those things that have an age limit IMO. I can totally see it on a girl in her 20s but for us double this age is better to stay away (unless you wear it to a Valentine's kids party or are a nursery school teacher IMO).
If you are looking for a Valentine's outfit and you are petite, the girl's pucker up skirt is adorable and more subtle (I ordered it for my daughter and I am tempted to order a 14 for me!)
gigiofca, again I think the heart me sweater is cute but the quality is Gap or F21 IMO. Glad that you like it though! At least it isn't itchy!
shopwithm, thanks! Yes, the colors in the bow skirt a a bit meh but maybe they will put out a more cheerful version? Someone on the JCA mentionned a cranberry color but it wasn't in my store.
WMM, yes that camel binding was a bad idea. I really liked the Joe Fresh ones but they are lighter, like a blend of cotton a rayon.
ina, I tried the thermal henley and didn't feel the love. It is plush and warm but looked like pajama-wear to me. I tried a S (one size up) and it fit well but someone said that they stretch out. HTH!
The heart sweater is cute, too bad they cheaped out n the fabric.
ReplyDeleteThose plaid pants are really cute but a bit loud. The tweed pencil skirt looks really good on you.
Thanks for sharing the photos and reviews, so helpful.
I had exactly the same reaction to that leopard dress! (and to daytime" sequins too!)
ReplyDeleteI love love the plaid pants and I am watching for a sale on those ones.
ReplyDeleteI can see them with a black turtleneck and a black wool trench coat over, since I saw them I have been thinking about them and that's very unusual as you know as I don't often wear pants!
I really like the tweed pencil on you it's really flattering. You should definitely look for that on sale!
Not fussed on the one with the bow.
Thanks for the great reviews you know we so appreciate it!
Hi Ema! Great post, I loved seeing all those pieces on you. The Heart Me sweater + the plaid Capris looked smashing, although I have seen the sweater in-store and hate the material so much!
ReplyDeleteI also saw that striped in-store only sweater and went right to it -- like you I was shocked to see the acrylic content selling for $180 in Canada!! Uh, no thanks! ;)
I think you look really nice in the plaid capris and the bow pencil skirt.
ReplyDeleteI tried on that heart sweater and was also disappointed in the quality. For some reason, my heart looked lopsided. It was not a good look.
Ema, this post was so helpful, thanks very much! I'm glad that you included the pic of you trying to lift your arms in the cashmere Fair Isle...it's been sitting in my online shopping cart and I've been itching to buy it, but that low-shouldered fit would probably bother me.
ReplyDeleteThose Wool Plaid Cafe Capris grow on me every time I see them...I'll watch for them in a post-holiday % off promo.
If you read the description of the Heart Me sweater, it is lopsided. It's perfectly imperfect and fun. I have it and love it and I'm way past my 20's and while I won't wear a mini skirt, I will happily wear my sweater and my sequin tops in the light of day.
ReplyDeleteLSS - I'm with you! I'm way past the age for wearing minis but yes to lopsided hearts and daytime sequins. I'll likely be an eccentric little old lady not paying attention to the rules for fashion. :)
ReplyDelete